Are you torn between an Apple Watch and a Garmin smartwatch for your fitness tracking needs?

This comprehensive guide will help you compare the latest features and performance of both devices in 2024 to make an informed decision.

Key Takeaways

• Garmin excels in battery life, custom workouts, and detailed training insights
• Apple Watch offers seamless integration with iOS devices and a versatile smartwatch experience
• Both provide accurate GPS and heart rate tracking, but with different strengths

Apple Watch vs Garmin: Comprehensive Comparison for Fitness Tracking

Hardware Specifications

Feature	Apple Watch Series 9	Garmin Fenix 7
Display	484 x 396 pixels (45mm)	260 x 260 pixels
Processor	S9 SiP	Not specified
Water Resistance	50 meters	100 meters
Battery Life	Up to 18 hours	Up to 18 days

Ease of Starting Workouts

Starting a workout should be effortless, especially when you’re ready to begin. Here’s how each device handles workout initiation:

Garmin

• Press the start/stop button
• Select workout type
• Wait for GPS signal
• Haptic feedback confirms start

Apple Watch

• Use touchscreen (Ultra version has a button)
• Series and SE models use a timer
• No waiting for GPS signal (except Ultra model)

Feature	Garmin	Apple Watch
Starting Workouts	Physical buttons, haptic feedback	Touchscreen, countdown timer
GPS Signal Waiting	Waits for good GPS signal	Only Ultra model do

Battery Life Comparison

Battery life is crucial for fitness enthusiasts. Let’s compare the two:

Garmin

• Up to 30 days without GPS
• Around 44 hours with GPS (selected models)
• Ideal for long-distance runners and travelers

Apple Watch

• Up to 18 hours (varies by model)
• 4-5 hours with GPS (Ultra model)
• Can last through a marathon with power management

Feature	Garmin	Apple Watch
Battery Life	Up to 30 days (non-GPS)	Up to 18 hours (varies by model)
GPS Usage	Up to 44 hours	4-5 hours (Ultra)
Charging Method	Traditional charging cable	Magnetic charger

Hardware Integration with External Sensors

For fitness enthusiasts relying on additional gadgets, sensor integration is crucial.

Garmin

• Seamless connectivity
• Prominently displays linked sensors during workouts
• Ensures data accuracy for performance monitoring

Apple Watch

• It requires checking connections through settings
• Less transparent about connected devices during workouts

Custom Workout Features and Display

Customization options can greatly enhance your workout experience:

Garmin

• Highly customizable workout displays
• Real-time updates on speed and heart rate zones
• Detailed data tracking during workouts

Feature	Garmin	Apple Watch
Custom Workout Displays	Highly customizable	Basic display, less real-time feedback
Real-Time Data Feedback	Detailed pacing and heart rate zones	Less glanceability

Apple Watch

• Basic customization options
• Less detailed real-time feedback
• Users may need to remember pacing details

Feature	Apple Watch	Garmin
Native Apps	20,000+	1,000+
Third-party Integration	Extensive	Limited but growing

GPS and Heart Rate Accuracy

Accuracy is paramount for serious athletes.

Garmin

• More comprehensive GPS signals
• Detailed heart rate information
• Beneficial for dedicated athletes and heart rate training

Apple Watch

• Accurate tracking
• May present smoother, potentially misleading heart rate data

Data Visibility During Workouts

Being able to quickly check your stats during a workout is crucial.

Garmin

• User-friendly interface
• Quick stat checks without text navigation
• Ideal for intense workouts

Apple Watch

• Vibrant display
• Compact size may pose readability challenges
• May hinder quick performance evaluation

Touchscreen Functionality and Accidental Inputs

Touchscreen functionality can be both a blessing and a curse during workouts.

Garmin

• Uses buttons to reduce accidental inputs
• Automatically locks screen during exercise sessions

Apple Watch

• Sensitive touchscreen, similar to iPhone
• No automatic locking mechanism during workouts
• Prone to accidental inputs from sweat or clothing

Comfort and Strap Options

Comfort is key for extended wear and exercise sessions.

Garmin

• Straps with ventilation holes
• Multiple breathable options

Apple Watch

• Ocean band with bumps for improved airflow
• Stylish and functional bands available

Both brands offer easy attachment/detachment systems for strap customization.

Feature	Garmin	Apple Watch
Strap Variety	Multiple breathable options	Stylish and functional bands available
Comfort During Use	Good ventilation and fit	Comfortable but can retain moisture

Sleep Tracking and Training Insights

Understanding your recovery is crucial for optimizing your training:

Garmin

• Detailed sleep monitoring
• Body battery and training readiness features
• Morning reports, including HRV and daily readiness

Apple Watch

• Basic sleep tracking (duration and stages)
• Less comprehensive recovery insights

Feature	Garmin	Apple Watch
Sleep Tracking	Detailed insights, body battery, training readiness	Basic sleep duration and stages
Morning Reports	Yes, including HRV and daily readiness	No dedicated morning report

Strava Integration

For many fitness enthusiasts, Strava integration is a must-have feature.

Garmin

• Direct sync from watch to app to Strava
• Seamless user experience

Apple Watch

• Requires data to pass through Apple Health first
• May experience delays or syncing issues

Feature	Garmin	Apple Watch
Strava Integration	Direct, reliable syncing	Requires Apple Health as an intermediary
Data Transfer Reliability	Generally consistent	Can experience delays

Price Comparison (2024 Models)

Model	Price Range
Apple Watch Series 9	$399 – $799
Apple Watch Ultra 2	$799 – $899
Garmin Fenix 7	$699 – $999
Garmin Forerunner 965	$599 – $699

Durability and Longevity

Both brands are known for their build quality, but Garmin devices generally have a longer lifespan due to their focus on outdoor activities.

User Testimonial: John, an avid hiker, shares, “My Garmin Fenix 5 is still going strong after 4 years of heavy use. It’s been through rain, snow, and countless trail runs.”

Accessibility Features

Apple Watch leads in accessibility with features like VoiceOver, zoom, and AssistiveTouch. Garmin has been improving but still lags behind in this area.

Environmental Impact

Both companies have made strides in sustainability.

• Apple: Carbon-neutral products by 2030 goal
• Garmin: Reduced packaging waste by 30% since 2020

Customer Support

Apple offers extensive support through its retail stores and online channels. Garmin provides good customer service but lacks the physical presence of Apple stores.

Integration with Other Devices

Apple Watch

• Seamless integration with iPhone and other Apple devices
• Works with some smart home devices via HomeKit

Garmin

• Compatible with both iOS and Android
• Integrates well with cycling computers and other fitness equipment

Future-Proofing

Apple typically releases new watch models annually, while Garmin has a longer update cycle but provides frequent software updates.

Conclusion: Making Your Choice

When it comes to choosing between the Apple Watch and Garmin, it really boils down to what you personally prefer and require. Here’s a brief overview to assist you in making your choice:

• Choose Garmin if you’re a serious athlete looking for:
  • • Detailed training insights
    • Superior battery life
    • Comprehensive fitness tracking

• Opt for Apple Watch if you want:
  • • A versatile smartwatch experience
    • Seamless integration with the Apple ecosystem
    • Good fitness capabilities with a focus on general health
• Remember, the best fitness tracker is the one that keeps you motivated and helps you achieve your fitness goals. Consider your lifestyle and fitness journey when making your decision.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Which watch has better battery life? Garmin generally offers significantly longer battery life, lasting up to 30 days without GPS, compared to the Apple Watch’s 18 hours.
• Is Garmin better for serious runners? Yes, Garmin provides superior custom workout features, sensor integration, and training insights, making it more suitable for serious runners.
• Can I use external sensors with both watches? Yes, both watches support external sensors, but Garmin offers better visibility and integration for connected devices.
• How do the sleep tracking features compare? Garmin provides detailed sleep insights and a morning report, while the Apple Watch offers basic sleep tracking capabilities.

Consider these factors and your needs when choosing between the Apple Watch and Garmin smartwatches. Both excel in their respective areas, so choose the one that aligns best with your fitness aspirations and lifestyle requirements.

Resources:

1. Nourish Move Love’s comparison article:
   https://www.nourishmovelove.com/garmin-vs-apple-watch/
   Updated for 2024, offers detailed feature comparison and personal insights.
2. TechRadar’s Best Fitness Trackers guide:
   https://www.techradar.com/best/best-fitness-trackers
   Comprehensive guide with specs comparison table and expert reviews.
3. CNET’s Best Smartwatch for 2024 guide:
   https://www.cnet.com/tech/mobile/best-smartwatch/
   In-depth reviews of both brands, focusing on fitness tracking capabilities.
4. Tim Anderson’s IT Writing blog post:
   https://www.itwriting.com/blog/12139-garmin-vs-apple-watch-why-i-switched.html
   Personal account of switching from Apple Watch to Garmin, emphasizing running features.
5. Hiking Guy’s YouTube video:
   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1r1F3Tv6lYQ
   Visual comparison based on two years of experience with both devices.